This traditional Orkney farmstead, which is now roofless, is comprehensively described in Alexander Fenton's account (1978, 116-118), which is illustrated with a plan, two sections and an elevation taken by RCAHMS in 1968, when the building remained largely intact (ORD/3/1; G 96106 S). It is now in some danger of collapse.
The farmstead comprises two ranges, both facing SE, set along the SE side of a large rectangular enclosure. The NE range measures about 28m from NE to SW by a maximum of 6m transversely over roughly coursed faced flagstone walls that still stand for the most part to full height. Only the dwelling at the NE end retains a portion of its original flagstone and turf covered roof, together with the timber framework that supported it, but even this is now poorly anchored and has begun to cave in. Nevertheless, the four compartments and the two bed-nooks remain intact, while the press and the fireplace with its iron swey in the kitchen survive, despite the fact that both are blocked with debris. However, the timber partitions that subdivided the ben in the middle of the range are long gone, as are the five box beds that once stood within it, while the walls of the byre at the SW end have partly fallen.
The SW range has been built on the same orientation as the NE range but is set slightly further towards the SE. It measures about 32m from NE to SW by 5.5m transversely over roughly coursed faced flagstone walls that stand largely to wall-head height. The interior contains three compartments and there is an outshot at each end. The SW half of the range is narrower than the NE half, a reflection of its earlier construction as evidenced by the 1st edition of the OS 6-inch map (Orkney 1882, Sheet XCIV). This SW end contained a barn, and a horse-engine platform, measuring about 10m in diameter, lies attached to the SE side of the building. The NE end of the range appears to have contained a byre, and two slab-built stalls project from the inner face of the NW wall, while two single doorways and a small window punctuate the SE facade. In the compartment between the byre and the barn there are the remains of a large rectangular flagstone bin which appears to have been a grain store. The outshot at the NE end of the range was a cart-shed.
The large rectangular yard measures roughly 80m from NE to SW by 40m transversely over flagstone walls. There is a gateway immediately SW of the SW range and a small rectangular enclosure, measuring roughly 13m from NNW to SSE by 8m transversely over flagstone rubble walls, lies within its W corner. This appears to have been accessed from the SSE. All that now remains of a probable garden enclosure that stood adjacent to the SE side of the NE range are its wall-footings.
There is also a WWII observation post situated immediately SE of the NE range. This measures about 3m from NE to SW by 2m transversely over flagstone rubble walls thinly rendered with concrete. Its flat roof remains intact and the building, which contains a large rectangular gun-port low down in the SE wall and a small rectangular aperture near the top left corner, was accessed by a central doorway on the NW. Its lintel has the following inscription outlined in capital letters in the wet cement: ‘Air Raid Shelter’. This was probably established to help protect the disused airfield of Skeabrae (HY22SE 59) situated some 600m to the W.
The farmstead is depicted roofed on the 1st and 2nd editions of the OS 6-inch map, together with the yards to the front and rear of both buildings. However, the small enclosure situated in the W corner of the large enclosure first appears on the 2nd edition of the map (Orkney 1903, Sheet XCIV). Visited by RCAHMS (ATW) 7 May 2013. [RCAHMS website 2014]
By June 2015, only a year after the above appeared on the RCAHMS website, Nether Benzieclett was a roofless ruin. I took a number of images, two of which appear for comparative purposes below those estimated to have been taken around 1930 at the foot of this page.
Nether Benzieclett was an example of what Clouston called a ‘half-and-half house’, i.e. a building which was “partly one-storey and partly two; or, as it was termed, a house with a two-storey ‘end.’ ”
In Orkney we find the half-and-half house in two forms. Most frequently the two-storey end was built on to a complete one-storey house. This type is clearly later than the other. In the older form the house was built all in one piece, and consisted, like the old one-storey houses, of two rooms divided by a cross wall, with an upper storey over only one of them.
So far, I have only found three specimens of the older form. The first, and oldest, is Nether Benzieclett, which has already been described. There the upper chamber was over the fire-house, and there is no evidence of a for-stue, or outer hall.
On looking back over the list of these old half-and-half Orkney houses, it is somewhat surprising, I think, that it should not be longer. Apart from one long vanished specimen at Quaquoy in Marwick, of which tradition remembers no details at all, I have not been able even to hear tell of any others in all the parishes I have visited. No doubt, of course, there were others which have vanished too long ago to be remembered at all, but they cannot have been numerous. Yet the type was very ancient, mentioned in many sagas; it was very common in Norway; and it certainly existed in our own islands at an early date. Nether Benzieclett, as we have seen, was partly two storey, and there is a curious record of another house, probably equally old, in the same parish of Sandwick.
MANSE OF CONSGAETH
The Rev. John Brand in his ‘Brief Description’ of Orkney published in 1701, has this interesting little passage: “Also,” he says, “the minister of Sandwick's Manse is said to have been the Residence of one of the Kings of Picts, and therefore to this day is called Koningsgar or, the King's House; And that part of the Manse, which they say served for the Palace of a King, is so litle, tho now keept in some Repair, that it could not accommodate a Family of an ordinary rank; The Figure thereof and contrivance of its two Rooms or Chambers one above and another below, of narrow dimensions, are antick (antique), and the Building hath been but course (coarse).”
Here we have an authentic account of a building in two stories, which was regarded as remotely ancient in 1700, and impressed an observer of that day by its antique appearance. The story of the Pictish King is, of course, not to be taken seriously, but it at least shows the building was so old that all memory and tradition of its true origin had been forgotten. I have no doubt myself it was really the two-storey end of an ancient house, whose one-storey portion had been replaced by the newer part of the manse. You can see exactly the same thing at Hoy Manse to-day, where half of a very old house still projects at the west end.
Since this kind of house, with the obvious convenience of an upper floor, occurred here so early, and since the type persisted as a building tradition through the 17th century, why should so very few of our older houses have a two-storey end? It is remarkable, for instance, that a house like Winksetter, so ambitious for the period, and with walls actually quite high enough at one end to carry an upper floor, should not have had one.
The only probable explanation that I can think of is want of wood for the flooring. Apart from that, nothing was lacking; the model was already here; and the advantages were evident. There was no wood of course in the islands, and one may take it we got our supplies, or far the greater part of them at least, from Norway. But there was a period during which it is impossible that this supply can have been maintained; the period of desolation that followed the appearance in Western Europe of the plague known as the Black Death. In 1349 and again in 1371 it swept through Norway with results so appalling that work of all kinds, in town and country, was well nigh paralysed for lack of workers. Referring to house-building, a Norwegian writer [Sundt in Bygningsskik] says that so many of the best carpenters having died, and the few people who survived being too busy with the necessities of daily life to engage in skilled work, a poorer and lighter type of timber work marks the houses erected after the plague. Manifestly there can have been neither much inclination nor much labour to fell and prepare timber for export.
If this really be the explanation (and I only offer it as what seems to me a very probable suggestion), it would seem to follow that the old houses of Benzieclett and Consgarth were built before 1349, and Winksetter and the other larger one-storey houses, after. Curiously enough there is some support for this view in the very matter just referred to; namely, the timber work. I have never seen elsewhere in Orkney such massive couples as support the roof of Nether Benzieclett; they are more like trees than beams. Obviously, good timber and plenty of it was obtainable when that roof was first put on. But at Winksetter, and indeed everywhere else, there is no wood-work of that sort.
Note the addition of a fine M.O.D. carbuncle on the southern side of the building shown in the first 2015 view. Stuck in the ‘middle of nowhere’ such a defensive structure might seem an exercise in futility, but Nether Benzieclett occupied a strategically important defensive position less than two miles south-east of R.A.F Skeabrae, one of only two R.A.F. airfields defending Orkney and Scapa Flow, the principle naval base in both world wars for the British Home Fleet. R.A.F Skeabrae was operational from 1940-57. No Germans made it past Nether Benzieclett.
Not everyone agrees with the antiquity of Nether Benzieclett as outlined above. In his chapter The Longhouse in Northern Scotland Alexander Fenton, at one time Director of the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, deals at some length with Nether Benzieclett as he does in his ‘The Northern Isles’ [Fenton, 1978]. Although he mistakenly places it in ‘Sandness’ rather than Sandwick, his views are in stark contrast to those of Clouston, RCAHMS, even though they cite him on their website (see above). Fenton sumarised his views thus. Nether Benzieclett appears as a simple three-unit longhouse, with byre, kitchen and ‘bedroom’, of the type that is characteristic of Orkney and elsewhere. The additions probably date to the second half of the 19th century. An 18th-century date for the original building can be postulated, but no single feature suggests an earlier date than this. The same can be said of several other Orkney longhouses that have been examined or re-examined ... and apart from the terminology of certain features, the Norseness of serviving longhouses is a very shadowy concept indeed. Fenton's views are echoed by the equally authoratitive Anna Ritchie. [Ritchie, 1996]
Just to add to the confusion, the meaning or derivation of the name Benzieclett is unclear, to put it mildly, one reason being that it was not always spelled Benzieclett. In Poll Tax records for Sandwick 1694 [Poll Lists of Sandwike 94 NAS RH9/15/175] it is spelled Bonyclyde and the householder named as Thomas Redland [not Redford!] Bonnyman is a coruption of benimann, and meant a clergyman, [Thomson, 1995]. There is a link here with the sea as neither clergyman nor kirk, among a host of other things, could be referred to openly by fishermen or those embarking on the sea without fear of inviting divine or other supernatural catastrophe, whereas bonnyman and bonnyhoose were acceptable alternatives. [Marwick, 1991] Bonyclyde and Benzieclett were presumably both as safe as houses. Gregor Lamb notes a possible relationship between klaet or cleat names in general with sites of ancient worship. It is quite clear...that in many cases a klaet could be a chapel in support of which he states the old house name Benzieclett in Sandwick...is baena-klaet prayer klaet. The Orkney Benzieclett name shows quite clearly that this type of building was a chapel or at least an oratory.
Finally, should you ever find yourself near Nether Benzieclett in the wee small hours, bear in mind that Orkney has had several animal ghosts. At the now  ruinous farmhouse of Nether Benzieclett, Sandwick, one of the oldest houses in the islands, where ‘a King of Norway once spent the night’, [one apparently sufficing] a man was supposed to have been murdered in the ale-hurry, a chamber in the wall where the ale was stored. [Marked A in the Benzieclett plan above] Ever afterwards a ghostly grey ewe came to the back of the ale-hurry at one o'clock each morning. [Marwick, 1975] So there you have it; the grey ewe did it in the ale-hurry and her apparition will be a convenient supply of wool for pulling over any eyes that happen to be open at the ungodly hour of her apparition.URLs active at the time of writing in January 2016.
© 2018 Duncan Linklater Custos Rotulorum.